Mary+Washington+ST+(Ben+Saunders+and+Terrell+Taylor)+Neg

=Kentucky Neg Strats=

Kentucky Round 1 v. USC HW (get rid of police cooperation for T-visas)
T - must be admissibility Cap K Trafficking K

2NR - Cap K

Kentucky Round 4 v. Emory CR (EB staples)
Clusters CP SKFTA DA Cap K Visa K

2NR - Cap K

Kentucky Round 5 v. JMU HK (Disease Exclusion open borders)
T - can't be admissibility SKFTA DA Visa K Exclude Contagious TB PIC

2NR - Visa K

Kentucky Round 8 v. Iowa KS (SIVs beneficiary eligibility expansion to Iraqis)
T - substantial Cap K SKFTA DA New Visa without Entitlements PIC (internal economy Net benefit)

2NR - Cap K

=Navy Neg Strats=

**Navy Round 2 v. Pitt HM (Include organ trafficking in T-visas)**
T - must read a plan Cap K Courts CP (ptx net benefit) SKFTA DA

2NR - Cap K

Navy Round 4 v. John Carroll BB (Amend TVPA to Palermo protocol)
Courts CP SKFTA DA Cap K Organized Crime DA

2NR - Courts/Politics

Navy Round 6 v. JMU HK (Lift H-1B cap)
Cap K SKFTA DA E-Verify Healthcare Education CP

2NR - Cap K

Navy Octas v. GMU OO (Open borders as homage to Ayn Rand)
T - must be admissibility Terrorism PIC SKFTA DA Protectionism DA

2NR - T/Terror PIC

=JMU Neg Strats (with that panchero kid aka the "pasa" aka what's up)=

JMU Round 1 v. JMU BM (lift H-1b cap)
Doctors PIC Wage Deflation DA SKFTA DA Protectionism DA

2NR - Protectionism DA

JMU Round 3 v. Clarion CS (Create Snitches Visa)
T - can't create a visa T - must be outside the U.S. Health Care Reform DA Visa K Illegal Immigrants Good on Case

2NR - Case turns

JMU Round 5 v. JMU BW (lift H-1B cap)
Doctor PIC Deflation SKFTA Protectionism

2NR - Protectionism DA

=UMW Neg Strats=

UMW Round 1 v. Clarion FS (Create Provisional Visas)
T - can't be a new visa ASPEC Courts Doctors PIC Health Care Repeal DA Cap K

2NR - Doctors PIC

UMW Round 3 v. JMU/WVU Hybrid (lift H-1B cap)
Commission CP Doctors PIC Health Care Repeal DA Cap K Protectionism DA

2NR - Protectionism DA

UMW Round 5 v. JMU HK (lift H-1B CAP)
Protectionism DA Health Care Repeal DA Doctors PIC Cap K

2NR - Doctors PIC

___

Topicality - Must be Admissibility
A. Interpretation – 1. Admissibility standards determine eligibility for visas Department of State, no date (US DoS Website, “Classes of Aliens Ineligible to Receive Visas,” no date given, [], accessed 10-23-10) PM  Section 212(a… to   be admitted to the U   nited   S   tates:

Cap K
A. The affirmatives logic of calculation reduces humanity to expressions of economic utility functions. The state becomes the tool of the market. Brown, Berkeley Political Theorist, 2003 [Wendy, Neo-liberalism and the End of Liberal Democracy, [], p.40-1, accessed 9-11-10, TP] The political sphere, along with …organization of "homeland security." B. Resisting this reliance on economic evaluation is the ultimate ethical responsibility – the current social order guarantees social exclusion on a global scale. Daly, University College of Northampton politics senior lecturer, 2004 [Slavoj and Glyn, Conversations with Zizek page 14-16] For Zizek it is imperative that … in an otherwise sound matrix. C. Completely withdraw from the ideology of capital – this is essential to destroy the fetish that allows capital to survive. Johnston, interdisciplinary research fellow in psychoanalysis at Emory University, 2004 [Adrian, Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society, December v9 i3 p259 page infotrac]

Perhaps the absence of a detailed … ("Capitalist commodity fetishism or the truth? I choose fetishism").

Trafficking K
Individualized Visas for trafficked persons ignore the root of trafficking. This framework enables a victimization of trafficked persons who are prioritized and privileged over undeserving migrants while trafficked persons are stripped of agency. Davidson, University of Nottingham, School of Sociology, 2010 [Julia, “New slavery, old binaries: human trafficking and the borders of ‘freedom’”, Global Networks 10, 2 (2010) 244–261, pg 256-257 JCP] There is no doubt … they employ to defend them.

Looking at trafficked persons as victims creates a Victorian ideal of purity that can only be protected by the West from the savage East. Doezema, Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex PhD Candidate, associate of the Network of Sex Work Projects, sex worker rights activist for ten years, 2001 [Jo, “ [|Ouch!] Western feminists' 'wounded attachment' to the 'third world prostitute'” Feminist Review, No. 67, Spring 2001 pp. 16-38, pg 24-26, JCP] Victorian feminists theoretically considered …f this feminist theorizing on prostitution. (1998: 13)

Western imperialism embedded in the orientalism reified in trafficking visas leads to extinction. William Eckhardt, Lentz Peace Research Laboratory of St. Louis, February 1990 , Journal of Peace Research, Vol. 27, No. 1, p. 15-16 Wright looked at the relation …. Life itself may depend upon our choice.

The alternative is to reject visas in order to open a space to deconstruct notions of modern-day slavery and create true freedom of movement. Davidson, University of Nottingham, School of Sociology, 2010 [Julia, “New slavery, old binaries: human trafficking and the borders of ‘freedom’”, Global Networks 10, 2 (2010) 244–261, pg 257-258 JCP] Talk of ‘ trafficking as modern slavery’ … it is an urgent political task.

Clusters CP
Text: The United States federal government should incentivize business cluster formation by creating an eligibility criterion to receive matched grants and prizes based on the merits of the cluster. The United States federal government should ban DoD procurement from foreign sources. The counterplan effectively boosts existing clusters and creates market incentives for clusters. Porter, Harvard Business School professor, revised in 2009 [Michael, “Clusters and Economic Policy: Aligning Public Policy with the New Economics of Competition” [], p.8-9, initially published in 2007, accessed 11-14-10, TP] A Federal program to enable … to all cluster group members. [Tom note- the criterion is in the card] Clusters solve all their econ internal links- boost productivity, skills, innovation, and efficiency. Martin, Mayer, Center for economic policy research, and Mayneris, Universite catholique de Louvain, 10-8-10 [Philippe, Thierry, and Mayer, “Public support to clusters A firm level study of French Local productive systems” [], p.3, accessed 11-14-10, TP] A typical defense of cluster … exchange of information and knowledge.

SKFTA DA
South Korea will overcome opposition now. Dayen, Fire Dog Lake, 2-3-11 [David, “When All You Have Left Defending You Is Max Baucus” [], accessed 2-3-11, TP] Virtually every time that Republicans or …don’t have much. Plan costs capital, that prevents passage of the agreement. Rodriguez, NYU Law Professor, 20  10  , (Cristina, “ARTICLE: FORTIETH ANNUAL ADMINISTRATIVE LAW ISSUE: IMMIGRATION LAW AND ADJUDICATION: CONSTRAINT THROUGH DELEGATION: THE CASE OF EXECUTIVE CONTROL OVER IMMIGRATION POLICY”, Duke Law Journal, 59 Duke L.J. 1787, PAS) Accessed on LexisNexis 10-8-10 Even if the president represents a national … conducive to the formation of consensus. Political capital now is essential to guarantee votes for ratification. Scott Linciome, Int'l Trade Attorney, Published Author, 11/23/20 10 , “Should Free Traders Be Concerned about KORUS and the Short-term Prospects for US Trade Policy? "http://lincicome.blogspot.com/2010/11/should-free-traders-be-concerned-about.html, access 12/20/10 * Second, the Seoul impasse proved without question … So far, Barack Obama hasn't.

Multilateral trade liberalization is impossible absent passage of SKFTA. Cooper et al, Specialist in international trade and finance coordinator, 11-12-10 [William, Mark E. Manyin, Specialist in Asian Affairs, Remy Jurenas, Specialist in Agricultural Policy, Michaela D. Platzer, Specialist in Industrial Organization and Business, “The Proposed U.S.-South Korea Free Trade Agreement (KORUS FTA): Provisions and Implications” [], p.45-6, accessed 2-4-11, TP] Since the early 2000s, U.S. use … with major trading partners. Multilateralism solves a coming great power war. Dyer, University of London Military History PhD, 200 4 (Gwynne, 12/30/4, "The end of war," Toronto Star, l/n [accessed 8/15/10]) War is deeply embedded in our history … within the context of the existing state system.

A. Interpretation- Eligibility and admissibility are distinct. Eligibility is qualifications for specific visas, whereas admissibility requirements apply to multiple visas Hasche, Parker, Butte & Lane, immigration law partner, 2005 [Tilman, "An Overview of Immigration Law," [], date of essay checked with author by email on 7-25-10, p.6-7, accessed 9-8-10, TP] 1. Predictable limits – they underlimit the topic to allow for huge affs and hyper specific affs that can apply to any different combination of visas Hasche, Parker, Butte & Lane, immigration law partner, 2005 [Tilman, "An Overview of Immigration Law," [], date of essay checked with author by email on 7-25-10, p.6-7, accessed 9-8-10, TP] Whether the alien … international child abductors.

Visa K
The preference system propagates conditional hospitality by ensuring that illegal persons are possible. Luibhéid, Bowling Green State University Ethnic Studies assistant professor, 2008 [Eithne, GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, “Sexuality, Migration, and the Shifting Line between Legal and Illegal Status” Project Muse, p, 290, accessed 12-12-10, TP] The narrative of immigrant America … law-abiding, or decent she or he is .4 The creation of a person who is illegal follows the neoliberal logic of disposability- some immigrants are deserving and others are a threat to the population. Luibhéid, Bowling Green State University Ethnic Studies assistant professor, 2008 [Eithne, GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, “Sexuality, Migration, and the Shifting Line between Legal and Illegal Status” Project Muse, p, 291, accessed 12-13-10, TP] Claims that anywhere from …, described in further detail below. Neoliberalism exists on the kill to save mentality, massive extermination of the other or collective suicide results in extinction. Santos, University of Coimbra Center for Social Studies director, 2003 [Boaventura de Sousa, “Collective suicide?” [], accessed 12-17-10, TP] It is above all appropriate to ask … of thousands of innocent civilians //.// The alternative is to reject the preference system in favor of interrogating hospitality to create an unconditional ethic for the other that stops violence against immigrants. Ajana, London School of Economics and Political Science researcher, 2006 [Btihaj, BA in Media Studies and Computing Science; MA in Digital Media University of London, Journal for Cultural Research vol 10 num 3, “Immigration interrupted” Ebsco, p.266, accessed12-19-10, TP] But while it might be objected that … disturbs the being at home with oneself’ (Levinas 1969, p. 39)4.

Counterplan Text: The United States Federal Government should remove all diseases from the list of communicable diseases of public health significance as grounds for inadmissibility for obtaining a visa except for those persons deemed to have contagious tuberculosis by medical professionals. That solves the aff and prevents TB spread and systemic death Schluger, Columbia University Medical Center professor, 8 (Neil, 4-25-08, Big Think, “Tuberculosis and the Immigration Question,” http://bigthink.com/ideas/905, accessed 1-20-11, CMM) Neil Schluger: Well, more … government cooperation for TB treatment.

Agamben
The affirmatives emphasis on visas entrenches the state’s ability to create exceptions to existing rules. Kasli, Ph.D. Candidate, and Parla , Assistant Anthropology Professor, Sabanci University, 2009 (Zeynep, and Ayse, Ph.D. Sociocultural Anthro at NYU, “Broken Lines of Il/Legality and the Reproduction of State Sovereignty: The Impact of Visa Policies on Immigrants to Turkey from Bulgaria” Alternatives 34 (2009), 203–227 AnthroSource [accessed 1/27/11] bs) We have argued that …exceptions to the rule. This ensures that the Filipinos let into the country are always subordinate to citizens with full political rights Kasli, Ph.D. Candidate, and Parla, Assistant Anthropology Professor, Sabanci University, 2009 (Zeynep, and Ayse, Ph.D. Sociocultural Anthro at NYU, “Broken Lines of Il/Legality and the Reproduction of State Sovereignty: The Impact of Visa Policies on Immigrants to Turkey from Bulgaria” Alternatives 34 (2009), 203–227 AnthroSource [accessed 1/27/11] bs) Various scholars have pointed to … the “exceptions to the rule.” The impact is totalitarianism and the end of democracy – we must separate bare life from sovereign’s sphere or be politically complicit with violence Agamben, 2005 (Giorgio, //State of Exception//, pp. 4-10 bs) The protagonist of this… constitute answers to these questions. The alternative is to Reject the plan and solutions found in the law in order to expose the law as a violent fiction. Agamben, College International de Philosophie professor, ‘05 (Giorgio, //State of Exception//, pp. 86-87 bs) It is from this perspective … or made juridical (Benjamin 1992, 41).